Jury duty on Wednesday was my third experience with this country’s court system in four months. By this point, I had grown incredibly weary of the whole idea and was quite certain that I was in for little more than several hours of sitting around waiting for something to happen that never would. I could hardly have been more prescient.
I showed up at 8:20, ten minutes early, and was the only juror that had arrived (out of the approximately seventy-five that would eventually appear). I proceeded to choose a chair, slouch down, and sleep for an hour before they started calling names. Fortunately for myself, I have no trouble whatsoever sleeping in public. The chairs weren’t particularly comfortable, but did I mention it was 8:30am? It was. I awoke briefly to watch a portion of a video where they told us how exciting and important it is to be a juror. It’s like someone got paid to market something that isn’t for sale. Hey videographer, didn’t anyone tell you we aren’t allowed to leave? You really don’t need to try so hard. Also, I strongly suspect that the parade of enthusiastic people with the title “Former Juror” wasn’t a representative sample. Where were all the people saying “yeah, it was pretty boring, but at least it got me out of work”?
When we got up to the courtroom, we were told that we’d be sitting in on a misdemeanor DUI case. The (very nice) judge spent a lot of time telling us about, you know, how awesome America is and how our jury trials rock the party like no other. Or something. It was sort of like a less endearing, more patriotic version of the previously mentioned video. The she started drawing names for potential jurors. She called 16, from which the goal (it later became clear) was to winnow it to 12 jurors and 2 alternates. While initially entertaining, my enthusiasm took a sharp turn off a cliff when I realized I’d be listening to jurors get questioned for the next four hours.
They asked the questions you’d expect. What neighborhood do you live in? What do the other adults in your household do for work? Have you been on a jury before? Do you hate Mexicans? That last one was implied, not asked outright. For the most part, the answers went about as you’d expect too: most people answered fairly directly and some people took the time to overshare about tangentially related things. A certain class of people did their best to prove themselves unqualified by claiming they were hopelessly biased. Most of these people were pretty unconvincing and transparent. No one had the balls to openly claim they hated Mexicans, but several people tried to claim they didn’t trust cops (ever!), didn’t trust people who drank, and one person claimed that DUI laws were unfair. The judge set the vast majority of them straight under repeated questioning. “So, even though you don’t think people should have a single drink if they’re going to drive, that’s not the law, and you don’t think you could apply the law in this case, even if you don’t agree with it?” They pretty much all relented under pressure from the judge.
After about an hour of jury questioning, the judge casually mentioned that the case was likely to go through Monday. Two potential jurors who were currently being questioned excused themselves saying they couldn’t be gone from work that long. Now I had a dilemma. I am going to DC for work on Monday. If I told the judge that, I’d have to reschedule my service within the next ninety days. But I’d already invested two hours into this exciting day. Should I admit my schedule conflict, go home, and come back some other day, once again at eight-freaking-thirty? Or should I wait it out, hope I don’t get picked, and be free from jury duty for a period of at least one year? If I got called up to be questioned, I’d be obligated to go home at that point. But by the time that happened, it could already be 1:30 or later, and then I would’ve have wasted a full five hours. (This ended up happening to one poor women.) In the end, my wait-and-see strategy prevailed and I got to go home without consequence.
I guess the most surprising thing to me is how much time these trials take. This was just a misdemeanor DUI case, and we spent five hours just selecting a jury! Then there were still three days of trial to go (those poor schmucks are still sitting in that courtroom as I type this). The Bill of Rights guarantees your right to a speedy trial, but that only applies to the time between arrest and the trial. Once the trial starts, all bets are off, it seems.